https://www.iotworldtoday.com/wp-content/themes/ioti_child/assets/images/logo/footer-logo.png
  • Home
  • News
    • Back
    • IoT World 2020 News
  • Strategy
  • Special Reports
  • Galleries
  • Business Resources
    • Back
    • Webinars
    • White Papers
    • Industry Perspectives
    • Featured Vendors
  • Other Content
    • Back
    • IoT World 2020 News
    • Q&As
    • Case Studies
    • Features
    • How-to
    • Opinion
    • Video / Podcasts
  • More
    • Back
    • About Us
    • Contact
    • Advertise
    • Strategic Partners
  • IOT World Events
    • Back
    • Internet of Things World: San Jose
    • IoT World 2020 News
Iot World Today
  • NEWSLETTER
  • Home
  • News
    • Back
    • IoT World 2020 News
  • Strategy
  • Special Reports
  • Galleries
  • Business Resources
    • Back
    • Webinars
    • White Papers
    • Industry Perspectives
    • Featured Vendors
  • Other Content
    • Back
    • IoT World 2020 News
    • Q&As
    • Case Studies
    • Features
    • How-to
    • Opinion
    • Video / Podcasts
  • More
    • Back
    • About Us
    • Contact
    • Advertise
    • Strategic Partners
  • IOT World Events
    • Back
    • Internet of Things World: San Jose
    • IoT World 2020 News
  • newsletter
  • IIoT
  • Cities
  • Energy
  • Homes/Buildings
  • Transportation/Logistics
  • Connected Health Care
  • Retail
  • AI
  • Architecture
  • Engineering/Development
  • Security
ioti.com

Supply Chain, Transportation & Logistics


Uber

Uber is planning on rolling out self-driving cars in Pittsburgh that doesn't

Waymo Hunt for Smoking Gun Turns to Uber Acquisition Report

Waymo says proof that its former engineer colluded with Uber Technologies Inc. to steal driverless technology can probably be found in a report the ride-hailing company commissioned in anticipation of a lawsuit.
  • Written by Bloomberg News
  • 30th May 2017

Now, the Alphabet Inc. unit is fighting to get ahold of the document as it prepares to go to trial against Uber in a trade-secrets case that could influence who wins the race to market self-driving cars.

Since Waymo sued in February, Uber and engineer Anthony Levandowski have steadfastly refused to turn over a due diligence report evaluating the risks associated with Uber’s acquisition of Otto LLC, the company Levandowski formed days after he quit Waymo. They argue it can’t be disclosed because it involves confidential communications between attorneys and clients.

Waymo claims that in 2015, Levandowski and Uber hatched a plan for him to steal more than 14,000 proprietary files, including the designs for lidar technology that helps driverless cars see their surroundings. Levandowski left Waymo in January 2016. Uber bought Otto in August for $680 million.

Levandowski, who isn’t a defendant in the lawsuit, has refused to testify, asserting his constitutional right against self-incrimination. Waymo argues that because he won’t answer questions about his negotiations with Uber and the allegedly stolen files, the information must be extracted from Uber, which as a corporation isn’t afforded the same constitutional protections as individuals.

The due diligence report “likely contains information that is responsive to many of the questions Mr. Levandowski refused to answer,” Waymo argued in a court filing. “Indeed, the withheld report may be the only source of much of this information.”

‘Red Flag’
U.S. Magistrate Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley said at a hearing Thursday in San Francisco that based on her closed-door review of the document, it’s important to the case and would need to be shared with Waymo unless there’s good reason to keep it secret. She didn’t reach any conclusion about whether Uber was justified in withholding it.

Corley also said Uber’s redactions to the documents it has disclosed that lay out the terms of the Otto acquisition and its unwillingness to share the entire term sheet with Waymo “raised a giant red flag.”

“What are you hiding?” she said. “What is the basis as you stand here today to continue to withhold that information from Waymo?”

She concluded there’s no basis for it being kept confidential and ordered Uber to turn it over by the end of the day. 

Uber has denied Waymo’s trade-secret theft allegations and says its automation technology has been developed without significant input from Levandowski.

‘Strong Showing’
U.S. District Judge William Alsup, who is overseeing the lawsuit, has expressed frustration with the shroud of secrecy around Uber’s dealings with Otto. In a May 11 ruling, the judge said it appears as if Uber “performed specialized ‘due diligence’ on Levandowski” to gird itself against any possible lawsuit “as a result of his move to Uber.” Concluding Waymo “made a strong showing” of trade-secrets theft, the judge asked federal prosecutors to investigate Waymo’s claims.

“How common is it to have an acquisition where every single document that bears on the acquisition is cloaked in privilege under a joint defense agreement?” Alsup asked Waymo’s lawyer, Charles Verhoeven, at a May 3 hearing.

“I’ve never seen it, your Honor,” Verhoeven said.

Alsup has tasked Corley with deciding whether the due diligence report must be turned over to Waymo.

A lawyer who represented Levandowski in the Otto deal with Uber explained the rationale for the report in a court filing.

“The litigation risk was particularly high due to the intensely competitive nature of the self-driving vehicle industry and the potentially billion-dollar commercial market involved,” the attorney said.

Uber spokeswoman Chelsea Kohler said Waymo isn’t legally entitled to see the report.

‘Sacred’ Privilege
“The report is protected by attorney-client privilege, which is the most sacred and important privilege in our entire legal system,” she said in an email. “The law simply does not support Waymo’s attempt to gut those privileges.”

A lawyer for Levandowski, Ismail Ramsey, told Corley his client has his own grounds for keeping the report secret.

Waymo spokesman Johnny Luu declined to comment ahead of Thursday’s hearing, as did the cyber-security firm that prepared the report, Stroz Friedberg.

Waymo argues that because the report wasn’t produced by lawyers, attorney confidentiality doesn’t apply. The company also contends the document doesn’t qualify for privacy protection because it may reveal fraudulent or criminal wrongdoing.

“There is substantial evidence that defendants and Mr. Levandowski were engaged in or planning a crime,” Waymo said in a court filing.

Uber countered in a filing that “Waymo has not even attempted to identify evidence that meets the elements of any ongoing crime or fraud.”

The case is Waymo LLC v. Uber Technologies Inc., 17-00939, U.S. District Court, Northern District of California (San Francisco).

Tags: Article Supply Chain, Transportation & Logistics Vertical Industries

Related


  • A Look at Michelin’s Product-as-a-Service Strategy
    A product-as-a-service strategy requires focusing on customer experience, according to Ralph Dimenna, a senior vice president at Michelin.
  • IoT Implementation Trends
    Most organizations have IoT plans but many aren’t sure how to achieve them
  • Image shows modern communication and transportation network
    Digital Supply Chain Transformation: The Role IoT and Blockchain Could Play
    With online commerce and the manufacturing sector on the upswing, and everything from IoT to blockchain to drones, delivery robots, and autonomous semi trucks and ships promising further advances, it’s arguably never been a better time to be in the supply chain and logistics business. Yet for logistics companies it can be challenging to meet […]
  • Navistar semi-truck
    Why Navistar’s OnCommand Connection Tech Is Groundbreaking
    The company’s CTO provides perspective on its fleet management tool.

Leave a comment Cancel reply

-or-

Log in with your IoT World Today account

Alternatively, post a comment by completing the form below:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Content

  • Connectivity Evolution: M2M vs. IoT vs. IoE
  • Smart Airport Technology Aims to Boost Customer Experience
  • Guided by Blockchain POCs, SAP Eyes Blockchain Consortium
  • Internet of Things Makes Tracking Affordable

News

View all

Private LTE Market Projected to Grow to $13 Billion

12th January 2021

IoT World Announces 2021 IoT World Advisory Board

9th December 2020

White Papers

View all

Smart and Flexible Automotive and Tire Production

20th December 2020

Unlock the Potential of Digital Transformation in Oil & Gas

15th December 2020

Special Reports

View all

Cybersecurity Protection Increasingly Depends on Machine Learning

28th October 2020

Webinars

View all

From Insights to Action: Best Practices for Implementing Connected Device Security

15th December 2020

Real Cyber Threats and Best Practices Cyber Security Strategy and Solutions for Smart Manufacturing

1st December 2020

Galleries

View all

Top IoT Trends to Watch in 2020

26th January 2020

Five of the Most Promising Digital Health Technologies

14th January 2020

Industry Perspectives

View all

IoT Spending Holds Firm — Tempered by Dose of ‘IoT Pragmatism’

1st December 2020

The Great IoT Connectivity Lockdown

11th May 2020

Events

View all

IoT at the Edge

17th March 2021

Embedded IoT World 2021

28th April 2021 - 29th April 2021

IoT World 2021

2nd November 2021 - 4th November 2021

Twitter

IoTWorldToday, IoTWorldSeries

#IoTsecuritytrends in 2021 will feature new threats given #remotework, #digitalhealth and #edgecomputing.… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

25th January 2021
IoTWorldToday, IoTWorldSeries

Protecting Your Network Against Ripple20 Vulnerabilities dlvr.it/RrJhpD https://t.co/Q2xe5hoy4U

25th January 2021
IoTWorldToday, IoTWorldSeries

The DOD turned to #kubernetes #containers for #IoTdevelopment to brace for rapid change. dlvr.it/RqzsLz https://t.co/t8W7coEdZN

20th January 2021
IoTWorldToday, IoTWorldSeries

Food for thought: Food and Beverage Industry eBook @ROKAutomation dlvr.it/Rqz00T https://t.co/Z3y18vuozF

20th January 2021
IoTWorldToday, IoTWorldSeries

Facility of the Future dlvr.it/Rqyzvm https://t.co/ytpsOUTtGP

20th January 2021
IoTWorldToday, IoTWorldSeries

A new day in automotive production #digitalmanufacturingsolutions @ROKAutomation dlvr.it/RqyrNS https://t.co/yxPFrBZGVg

20th January 2021
IoTWorldToday, IoTWorldSeries

Unlock the potential of digital transformation in Oil & Gas @ROKAutomation dlvr.it/RqyrBV https://t.co/kzHcGjf2OK

20th January 2021
IoTWorldToday, IoTWorldSeries

.@Airbus’s #datdriven #digitaltransformation focused on getting its existing data in order rather than just gatheri… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

19th January 2021

Newsletter

Sign up for IoT World Today newsletters: vertical industry coverage on Tuesdays and horizontal tech coverage on Thursdays.

Special Reports

Our Special Reports take an in-depth look at key topics within the IoT space. Download our latest reports.

Business Resources

Find the latest white papers and other resources from selected vendors.

Media Kit and Advertising

Want to reach our audience? Access our media kit.

DISCOVER MORE FROM INFORMA TECH

  • IoT World Series
  • Channel Futures
  • RISC-V
  • Dark Reading
  • ITPro Today
  • Web Hosting Talk

WORKING WITH US

  • Contact
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Login/Register

FOLLOW IoT World Today ON SOCIAL

  • Privacy
  • CCPA: “Do Not Sell My Data”
  • Cookies Policy
  • Terms
Copyright © 2021 Informa PLC. Informa PLC is registered in England and Wales with company number 8860726 whose registered and Head office is 5 Howick Place, London, SW1P 1WG.
This website uses cookies, including third party ones, to allow for analysis of how people use our website in order to improve your experience and our services. By continuing to use our website, you agree to the use of such cookies. Click here for more information on our Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy.
X